Portions: 1
Total time: 1 hour 45 minutes
Difficulty: Easy
Inspired by the bustling New York City halal carts, this Chicken Over Rice recipe brings together tender, marinated chicken, fluffy yellow rice, crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and the iconic creamy white sauce in a healthy, homemade version that doesn’t sacrifice taste for nutrition. Whether you live miles away from NYC or simply prefer a lighter, less greasy meal, this dish is your answer to craving the flavors of the city streets right from your kitchen.
Preparing this recipe is a celebration of freshness and robust flavor. The marinated chicken is the true star: a medley of garlic, Greek yogurt, tangy lemon juice, and an aromatic blend of spices infuses every bite with irresistible taste and moisture. Allowing the chicken to rest in this marinade for at least an hour (or more if time permits) enhances tenderness, ensuring juicy results once grilled or sautéed.
The rice, a gorgeous yellow hue thanks to a dash of turmeric, is cooked gently in chicken broth for maximum flavor and fluffy texture, with just the right hint of cumin. Using long-grain basmati rice brings the authenticity of New York's famous carts and guarantees a pillowy light base for the bold toppings.
The creamy white sauce, a cult favorite, marries everything together. It’s a simple, tangy mix of light mayo, Greek yogurt, lemon, and freshly grated garlic with a dash of black pepper and a touch of sweetness—a drizzle takes every bite to the next level.
Crunchy lettuce and chopped tomatoes not only add freshness and balance but also round out the plate, turning this into a complete meal that's as vibrant to the eye as it is to the tastebuds.
From start to finish, this dish is approachable and easy to double or triple for meal prep or a small gathering. It’s perfect for lunch, dinner, or any moment when only something satisfying, fresh, and bold will do. Make it once, and it just might join your regular weeknight rotation.
Difficulty: Easy
Preparation time: 15 minutes
Cooking time: 30 minutes
Cooking method: Stovetop
Resting time: 1 hour (for marinating)
Total time: 1 hour 45 minutes
Portions: 1
Estimated cost: Low
Calories: 574 per serving
Best time to eat: Lunch or dinner
Best season for eating: Any season
Cuisine: Mediterranean/Middle Eastern inspired street food
Course: Main
✅ Quick Tips:
Letting the chicken marinate overnight will make it extra tender and flavorful.
Taste and adjust salt and spices as needed in both the chicken marinade and the white sauce.
The rice can be made in advance and reheated gently before serving.
Swap chicken thigh for chicken breast for a leaner option, but note the final dish will be less juicy.
Adjust the red chili powder for more or less heat according to personal preference.
Make extra white sauce—it keeps in the fridge for up to three days and is delicious on salads or other proteins.
For meal prep, store chicken, rice, and veggies separately and assemble fresh for the best texture.
Try adding hot sauce or chili oil for NYC-style “red sauce” heat.
To make vegetarian, swap chicken for paneer or tofu and use water or vegetable broth in the rice.
This Chicken Over Rice recipe brings together tender, marinated chicken, fluffy yellow rice, crisp lettuce, tomatoes, and the iconic creamy white sauce in a healthy, homemade version that doesn’t sacrifice taste for nutrition. Whether you live miles away from NYC or simply prefer a lighter, less greasy meal, this dish is your answer to craving the flavors of the city streets right from your kitchen.
Preparing this recipe is a celebration of freshness and robust flavor. The marinated chicken is the true star: a medley of garlic, Greek yogurt, tangy lemon juice, and an aromatic blend of spices infuses every bite with irresistible taste and moisture. Allowing the chicken to rest in this marinade for at least an hour (or more if time permits) enhances tenderness, ensuring juicy results once grilled or sautéed.